Short Cuts: 5 Fleetwood Mac songs by Christine McVie who was born July 12, 1943.

1. “Oh Daddy” – ‘Rumours’ (1977)

“Oh Daddy” is one of the most hauntingly understated songs on Rumours, and perhaps one of Christine McVie’s most emotionally enigmatic compositions. Written for Mick Fleetwood, the band’s de facto leader and the only actual “Daddy” at the time, the song walks a delicate line between reverence and quiet melancholy. McVie’s warm, soulful delivery is drenched in resignation and subtle tension, reflecting the emotional disarray plaguing the band during the album’s recording. The slow tempo, cascading piano lines, and ghostly harmonies from Stevie Nicks and Lindsey Buckingham create a hypnotic, dreamy atmosphere. Lyrically, it’s deceptively simple—an appeal to someone who seems to hold power and yet doesn’t always use it wisely. There’s a vulnerability that feels personal, even though its meaning remains deliberately opaque. The emotional weight is amplified by the production, which leans into reverb and space, allowing each instrument—particularly the keyboards and rhythm section—to breathe. John McVie’s fretless bass part is spectacular. It’s a testament to McVie’s skill in crafting songs that evoke complex emotions with apparent ease. “Oh Daddy” may be overshadowed by Rumours’ blockbuster hits, but it’s a slow-burning gem that shows her ability to anchor a chaotic moment with grace, restraint, and quiet emotional power. 

⸻

2. “Why” – ‘Mystery To Me’ (1973)

Featured on Fleetwood Mac’s Mystery to Me, “Why” is one of Christine McVie’s most elegant early compositions—a blend of heartbreak, introspection, and subtle optimism. The song begins with a gently rolling piano figure and warm electric piano chords that instantly set a mellow, introspective tone. McVie’s voice is at its most vulnerable here, and her lyrics—“Why, why do you treat me so bad / So bad when you’re the best I’ve ever had?”—cut with their plainspoken honesty. The track builds slowly, layering soft harmonies and understated instrumental flourishes, including a subtle guitar solo by Bob Weston that enhances the emotional resonance without overpowering the mood. What sets “Why” apart is its grace: it’s neither accusatory nor bitter, just quietly aching. McVie channels a kind of sadness that feels lived-in and deeply human. The arrangement reflects her strength as a musical minimalist, favoring feel over flash. As a closer on Mystery to Me, the song is a perfect bookend—its gentle sadness lingers long after the last note fades. “Why” may not be a chart hit, but it is quintessential McVie: emotional honesty wrapped in musical warmth and elegant restraint. Soon to be fired guitarist Bob Weston adds a particularly stunning slide guitar part which supports the song’s mournful theme. 

⸻

3. “Brown Eyes” – ’Tusk’ (1979)

“Brown Eyes,” from Fleetwood Mac’s ambitious Tusk, is a subtle and smoldering Christine McVie track that thrives on atmosphere and suggestion. Where Tusk often indulges in experimental flourishes and sonic detours, “Brown Eyes” stands out for its languid sensuality and minimalist elegance. McVie’s smoky vocals glide over a slow-burning groove, and her restrained delivery lends the song a cool, almost detached intimacy. The lyrics are fragmentary and impressionistic, suggesting longing and infatuation without ever tipping into sentimentality. The track also famously features uncredited guitar work from former bandmate Peter Green, whose bluesy, haunting tone adds a spectral layer to the song. The interplay between the guitars, McVie’s Rhodes piano, and the brushed drums is hypnotic, conjuring a late-night vibe that’s more about mood than narrative. “Brown Eyes” is a masterclass in subtlety—nothing shouts, everything breathes. It’s one of the most understated tracks on Tusk, but its quiet confidence makes it unforgettable. In McVie’s catalog, it’s a reminder that her power as a songwriter lies not just in melody but in emotional suggestion—she paints with feeling rather than flash, and the result is quietly devastating. A great song among great songs from the band’s best album. 

⸻

4. “All Over Again” – ’Time’ (1995)

“All Over Again,” from Time, is Christine McVie’s graceful goodbye to Fleetwood Mac before her departure from the band in the late 1990s. It’s a song steeped in weary wisdom and emotional clarity. Unlike the complex interpersonal turmoil that fueled many earlier Fleetwood Mac classics, this track presents a mature, composed reflection on the end of a relationship—and perhaps, symbolically, the end of an era. McVie’s voice, rich with pathos and resignation, carries lyrics that speak of love, forgiveness, and the decision not to repeat painful cycles: “Well it’s time to say goodbye / And I know that you’re going, but I’ll survive.” The ballad is stripped-down and elegant, relying on piano, soft percussion, and understated guitar to underscore the emotional depth without melodrama. McVie’s songwriting here is direct and quietly powerful—there’s no bitterness, just a gentle strength in choosing self-preservation. “All Over Again” feels like a farewell letter, both personal and professional, and it gains poignancy in hindsight, knowing she stepped away from the band soon after. It’s one of her most mature and affecting compositions—quietly dignified, emotionally sincere, and a fitting coda to a remarkable era. As with all of McVie’s compositions on ’Time’ “All Over Again” was recorded by her own production team in England and did not feature Dave Mason on guitar of vocals. Despite the drama, McVie’s songs on ’Time’ are  bright spots on a rather dull album. “All Over Again” replaced “Songbirds” as the encore on the last Fleetwood Mac tour. 

⸻

5. “You Make Loving Fun” – “Rumours” (1977)

Christine McVie has a lot of song about sex. “You Make Loving Fun” is one of the sunniest, most infectious songs on Rumours, showcasing Christine McVie’s gift for writing joyful, melodic pop that still carries emotional nuance. Written about her relationship with Fleetwood Mac’s lighting director, Curry Grant, the song is a celebration of newfound love wrapped in a funky, keyboard-driven groove. McVie’s clavinet lines give the track its buoyant pulse, while the rhythm section—John McVie and Mick Fleetwood—lays down one of the album’s most danceable backbeats. Vocally, McVie shines: her delivery is warm, playful, and quietly assertive. Lyrically, the song feels like an exhale after emotional turbulence, a declaration that love can still feel light and revitalizing: “I never did believe in miracles / But I’ve a feeling it’s time to try.” The irony of singing such an upbeat love song amid the band’s internal chaos adds a fascinating layer of complexity. Yet it never feels cynical. It’s that emotional honesty wrapped in groove and sparkle that makes the track endure. “You Make Loving Fun” is quintessential McVie—joyful without being saccharine, emotionally grounded yet musically uplifting. It remains a high point not just on Rumours, but in Fleetwood Mac’s entire discography.

⸻